For many private companies, the board of directors exists on paper but does not always function as a true governance body. Meetings may be informal, decisions may happen outside the boardroom, and directors may be too involved in day-to-day management.
For many private companies, the board of directors exists on paper but does not always function as a true governance body. Meetings may be informal, decisions may happen outside the boardroom, and directors may be too involved in day-to-day management.
As a company grows, this approach can create serious weaknesses.
The board should provide oversight, challenge and strategic direction—not simply approve documents after decisions have already been made.
For UAE private companies, establishing an effective board structure can help improve accountability, strengthen decision-making and prepare the business for its next stage of growth.
The exact governance requirements will depend on the company's legal form, jurisdiction, activity and applicable legislation.
What Makes an Effective Board?
A strong board is not necessarily a large board.
It is a board with:
- Clear responsibilities
- The right mix of skills
- Appropriate independence
- Effective meetings
- Reliable information
- Constructive challenge
- Clear decision-making authority
- Accountability
The board should provide a level of oversight that complements management rather than competing with it.
1. Define the Board's Role Clearly
One of the most common problems in private companies is the lack of distinction between the board and management.
The board should generally focus on:
- Strategy
- Major investments
- Risk
- Financial performance
- Governance
- Senior leadership
- Major transactions
- Long-term direction
Management should focus on:
- Daily operations
- Sales
- Customers
- Employees
- Execution
- Operational decisions
When these responsibilities become blurred, directors can become too involved in operations while management loses accountability.
2. Establish Clear Board Responsibilities
The board should have a clearly defined mandate.
Depending on the company, this may include responsibility for:
Strategy
Reviewing and approving the company's strategic direction.
Financial Oversight
Monitoring financial performance, budgets, forecasts and major financial commitments.
Risk
Understanding the company's material risks and whether appropriate controls exist.
Leadership
Overseeing the appointment, performance and succession of senior executives.
Governance
Ensuring that appropriate governance policies and procedures are in place.
Major Transactions
Reviewing significant acquisitions, investments, financing and strategic partnerships.
A board cannot provide effective oversight if it is unclear what it is actually responsible for.
3. Appoint Directors Based on Skills, Not Only Relationships
In private and family-owned companies, directors are sometimes appointed primarily because of family relationships, ownership or seniority.
Relationships may be important.
But the board also needs the right capabilities.
Depending on the business, this could include expertise in:
- Finance
- Strategy
- Legal
- Operations
- Technology
- Risk
- Industry knowledge
- International expansion
- M&A
A board skills matrix can help identify what expertise already exists and where gaps remain.
4. Consider Independent Board Perspective
An independent perspective can be particularly valuable for private companies.
An independent director or adviser can challenge management assumptions without being directly involved in family or shareholder dynamics.
This can be useful when the company is considering:
- Major investments
- Acquisitions
- Related-party transactions
- Succession
- Restructuring
- Expansion
- External investment
Independence does not mean being opposed to management.
It means being able to challenge constructively and make decisions based on the company's interests.
5. Create a Board Calendar
Effective boards should not meet only when something needs to be approved.
A structured annual board calendar can ensure that important topics are addressed throughout the year.
For example:
Q1
- Annual strategy
- Budget
- Prior-year performance
- Risk review
Q2
- Financial performance
- Operational performance
- Strategic initiatives
Q3
- Forecast
- Workforce
- Major projects
- Risk review
Q4
- Next year's strategy
- Budget
- Board effectiveness
- Executive performance
The exact agenda should reflect the company's priorities.
6. Prepare High-Quality Board Papers
Board meetings are only as effective as the information provided to directors.
Board packs should provide directors with enough information to:
- Understand performance
- Identify risks
- Challenge assumptions
- Make informed decisions
A strong board pack may include:
- Management accounts
- KPI dashboard
- Cash-flow position
- Budget vs actual
- Forecast
- Risk register
- Major contracts
- Strategic initiatives
- Matters requiring approval
The objective is decision-useful information, not hundreds of pages of reports.
7. Make Board Meetings About Decisions, Not Presentations
A board meeting should not simply become a series of management presentations.
The most valuable board discussions usually focus on:
What is happening?
Why is it happening?
What does it mean for the business?
What are the options?
What decision is required?
Management should provide the information.
The board should provide oversight, challenge and direction.
8. Establish a Formal Decision and Approval Process
A board should have clarity around which matters require board approval.
This can be documented through:
- Board reserved matters
- Delegation of authority
- Approval thresholds
- Shareholder reserved matters
Examples may include:
- Major capital expenditure
- Significant borrowing
- Acquisitions
- Disposal of material assets
- New business ventures
- Major contracts
- Related-party transactions
- Appointment or removal of senior executives
This avoids uncertainty and reduces the risk of decisions being made without the appropriate authority.
9. Manage Conflicts of Interest
Conflicts of interest are particularly important in private and family-owned companies.
A director may have:
- A personal relationship with a supplier
- An interest in another company
- A family member involved in a transaction
- A financial interest in a proposed arrangement
The board should have an appropriate process for:
- Declaring the conflict
- Recording it
- Determining how it should be managed
- Limiting participation where appropriate
- Documenting the decision
Transparency protects both the company and the directors.
10. Maintain Proper Board Minutes
Board minutes should provide a clear record of:
- Attendees
- Matters discussed
- Conflicts declared
- Decisions made
- Approvals granted
- Actions assigned
Good minutes are not simply a transcript of the meeting.
They should provide an accurate governance record showing what was considered and what was decided.
11. Monitor Financial Performance
Financial oversight is one of the board's most important responsibilities.
Directors should have visibility over:
- Revenue
- Gross margin
- EBITDA
- Cash flow
- Working capital
- Debt
- Capital expenditure
- Budget performance
- Forecast
- Key financial risks
The board should not necessarily manage the finance function.
Its role is to challenge and oversee financial performance.
12. Put Risk on the Board Agenda
Risk management should be an ongoing board responsibility.
The board should understand the company's most significant risks, including:
- Financial
- Operational
- Legal
- Regulatory
- Cybersecurity
- People
- Reputational
- Strategic
A board-level risk register can help directors understand:
What are our biggest risks?
Who owns them?
What controls exist?
Are the risks increasing or decreasing?
13. Oversee Senior Management Performance
The board should not only monitor financial results.
It should also evaluate whether management is delivering against the company's strategic objectives.
This may include reviewing:
- CEO performance
- Executive KPIs
- Strategic initiatives
- Leadership capability
- Succession plans
- Management compensation
The board should provide appropriate challenge without becoming involved in day-to-day management.
14. Plan for CEO and Leadership Succession
One of the biggest risks for a private company is being overly dependent on one individual.
What happens if:
- The founder retires?
- The CEO leaves?
- A key executive becomes unavailable?
- The company enters a new phase requiring different leadership?
A board should consider succession before it becomes urgent.
This is particularly important for family-owned businesses moving from one generation to another.
15. Review Board Effectiveness
A board should periodically ask:
Are we actually adding value?
A board effectiveness review can assess:
- Board composition
- Skills
- Meeting effectiveness
- Quality of information
- Strategic contribution
- Director participation
- Relationship with management
- Committee effectiveness
The objective is continuous improvement.
16. Use Committees Where Appropriate
Not every private company needs multiple board committees.
However, as the company becomes more complex, committees can provide additional focus.
Potential committees include:
- Audit & Risk Committee
- Remuneration Committee
- Nomination Committee
- Investment Committee
- Executive Committee
The structure should be proportionate to the company's size and complexity.
17. Keep Shareholder and Board Matters Separate
Shareholders and directors have different roles.
Shareholders own the company.
Directors govern the company.
Management runs the company.
In smaller private companies, the same individuals may occupy all three roles.
That is perfectly possible.
The challenge is ensuring that each individual understands which role they are acting in when making a decision.
This becomes increasingly important when ownership becomes more distributed.
18. Encourage Constructive Challenge
A board where everyone agrees with the CEO is not necessarily an effective board.
Directors should be able to ask difficult questions.
For example:
- What assumptions support this forecast?
- What happens if revenue falls 20%?
- Why are margins declining?
- What are the alternatives?
- What is the downside?
- What are competitors doing?
- Are we taking too much risk?
Constructive challenge helps management make better decisions.
Common Board Mistakes in Private Companies
Private companies should be particularly careful about:
1. The founder dominates every discussion
The board becomes a formality rather than a genuine governance body.
2. Directors are too operational
The board becomes involved in daily management.
3. No clear agenda
Important strategic and risk matters are overlooked.
4. Poor board information
Directors receive information too late or in an unusable format.
5. No formal decision framework
It is unclear which matters require board approval.
6. Family relationships override governance
Business decisions become driven by personal relationships.
7. No succession planning
The company becomes overly dependent on one individual.
8. Meetings focus entirely on historical results
The board spends too little time discussing future risks and opportunities.
A Practical Board Framework for Growing Private Companies
A practical governance structure could look like:
Shareholders
↓
Board of Directors
↓
Board Committees — where appropriate
↓
CEO / Managing Director
↓
Management Team
↓
Business Operations
Supported by:
Risk Management | Internal Controls | Financial Reporting | Legal & Compliance
This creates a clear chain of accountability while allowing management to operate efficiently.
How SHAAS Supports Boards of Private Companies
At SHAAS, we help private and family-owned businesses strengthen board effectiveness and corporate governance.
Our support can include:
- Board structure and governance reviews
- Board charters
- Board calendars
- Board reporting frameworks
- Board paper development
- Delegation of authority
- Reserved matters
- Board effectiveness reviews
- Risk and control oversight
- Committee structures
- Director roles and responsibilities
- Succession planning
- Family business governance
- Corporate governance frameworks
We help businesses move from informal governance to structured, commercially focused oversight without creating unnecessary bureaucracy.
A Strong Board Should Help the Business Move Forward
A board should not be viewed simply as a legal requirement or approval body.
An effective board can become one of the company's most valuable strategic assets.
It should help management:
Challenge assumptions.
Identify risks.
Evaluate opportunities.
Maintain accountability.
Make better decisions.
Prepare for the future.
For a growing private company, the question is not whether it needs a larger board.
The question is whether its current board is providing the level of oversight and strategic value the business now requires.
